Philosophy · Saylor PHIL102

Logic and Critical Thinking

This course provides an introduction to critical thinking, informal logic, and a small amount of formal logic. Its purpose is to provide you with the basic tools of analytical reasoning, which will give you a distinctive edge in a wide variety of careers and courses of study.

More about this course

While many university courses focus on the presentation of content knowledge, the emphasis here is on learning how to think effectively. Although the techniques and concepts covered here are classified as philosophical, they are essential to the practice of nearly every major discipline, from the physical sciences and medicine to politics, law, and the humanities. The course touches upon a wide range of reasoning skills, from verbal argument analysis to formal logic, visual and statistical reasoning, scientific methodology, and creative thinking. Mastering these skills will help you become a more perceptive reader and listener, a more persuasive writer and presenter, and a more effective researcher and scientist. The first unit introduces the terrain of critical thinking and covers the basics of meaning analysis, while the second unit provides a primer in analyzing arguments. All of the material in these first units will be built upon in subsequent units, which cover informal and formal logic, Venn diagrams, scientific reasoning, as well as strategic and creative thinking.

Upon successful completion of this course, students will be able to:

In order to take this course you must: √ have access to a computer; √ have continuous broadband Internet access; √ have the ability/permission to install plug-ins or software (e.g., Adobe Reader or Flash); √ have the ability to download and save files and documents to a computer; √ have the ability to open Microsoft files and documents (.doc, .ppt, .xls, etc.); √ be competent in the English language; and √ have read the Saylor Student Handbook.

Chapter I

Introduction and Meaning Analysis

Critical thinking is a broad classification for a diverse array of reasoning techniques. In general, critical thinking works by breaking arguments and claims down to their basic underlying structure, so we can see them clearly and determine whether they are rational. The idea is to help us do a better job of understanding and evaluating what we read, what we hear, and what we ourselves write and say.

Basic Overview of Critical Thinking

  1. Critical ThinkingUniversity of British Columbia’s Learning Commons · watch · 15 min

The Nature and Value of Critical Thinking

  1. Tutorials C01–C04University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Thinking Skills · read · 30 min · no longer online

Review of Introduction to Critical Thinking

  1. PHIL102 Discussion ForumThe Saylor Foundation · do · 30 min · archived copy

The Elements of Meaning

  1. Introduction–Tutorial M05University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Meaning Analysis: · read · 2 h · no longer online
  2. PHIL102 Discussion ForumThe Saylor Foundation · do · 30 min · archived copy

Necessary and Sufficient Conditions

  1. Tutorial M06University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Meaning Analysis · read · 30 min · no longer online

Thinking Critically about Ordinary Language

  1. Tutorials M08–M10University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Meaning Analysis · read · 2 h · no longer online

General Strategies for Assessing Sources

  1. Information Skills TutorialEmpire State College Online Library · read · 2 h · archived copy

Checklists for Assessing Sources

  1. Evaluating Information Sources: Basic Principles and Evaluating Web PagesDuke University Libraries · read · 2 h · archived copy

Assessing Internet Sources

  1. Evaluating Internet MaterialBoundless · read · 1 h · no longer online

Review of Assessing Sources

  1. PHIL102 Discussion ForumThe Saylor Foundation · do · 30 min · archived copy

Chapter II

Argument Analysis

Arguments are the fundamental components of all rational discourse. Nearly everything we read and write—scientific reports, newspaper columns, personal letters, and most of our verbal conversations as well—contains arguments. Picking them out from the rest of our (often messy) discourse can be difficult though. Once we have identified an argument, we still need to determine whether or not it is sound. Luckily, arguments obey a set of formal rules, which we can use to determine whether they are good or bad. In this unit, we will learn how to identify arguments, what makes an argument sound (as opposed to unsound or merely valid), the difference between deductive and inductive reasoning, and how to map arguments to reveal their structure.

John Pettie - Reductio Ad Absurdum
John Pettie - Reductio Ad Absurdum, John Pettie, 2015-11-11. Public domain

What Arguments Are

  1. The Nature of ArgumentsiTunes U · University of Oxford · Professor Marianne Talbot’s Critical Reasoning for Beginners: · watch · 1 h

How to Tell an Argument from a Non-Argument

  1. Tutorials A01 and A02University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Argument Analysis · read · 1 h · no longer online

Validity and Soundness

  1. Tutorials A03–A05University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Argument Analysis: · read · 2 h · no longer online
  2. Introduction to Logic Quiz: Truth, Validity, and SoundnessLander University · Lee C. Archie · write · 30 min

More about Good Argument Form

  1. Tutorials A06–A08University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Argument Analysis · read · 1 h · no longer online
  2. Different Types of ArgumentsiTunes U · University of Oxford · Marianne Talbot’s Critical Reasoning for Beginners: · watch · 1 h

Visualizing How Arguments Work

  1. Tutorial A09University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Argument Analysis: · read · 1 h · no longer online

Analogical Arguments

  1. Tutorial A10University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Argument Analysis · read · 1 h · no longer online

Valid Argument Patterns

  1. Tutorial A11University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Argument Analysis: · read · 1 h · no longer online

Review of Argument Analysis

  1. PHIL102 Discussion ForumThe Saylor Foundation · do · 30 min · archived copy

Chapter III

Fallacies

Now that we have an understanding of the structure that good arguments need to have and can represent their structure visually, we might think it would be a simple matter to pick out the bad ones. However, identifying bad arguments can be very tricky in practice. Very often what at first appears to be ironclad reasoning turns out to contain one or more subtle errors. Fortunately, there are a large number of easily identifiable “fallacies”—mistakes of reasoning that we can learn to recognize by their structure or content. In this unit, we will learn about the nature of fallacies, look at a couple of different ways of classifying them, and spend some time dealing with the most common fallacies in detail.

Italian:  Cicerone denuncia CatilinaCicero Denounces Catilinetitle QS:P1476,it:"Cicerone denuncia Catilina"label QS:Lit,"Cicerone denuncia Catilina"label QS:Les,"Cicerón denuncia a Catilina"label QS:Lfr,"Cicéron dénonce Catalina"label QS:Lla,"icero Catilinam incusat"label QS:Lde,"Cicero klagt Catilina an"label QS:Len,"Cicero Denounces Catiline"
Italian: Cicerone denuncia CatilinaCicero Denounces Catilinetitle, Cesare Maccari, 1889. Public domain

Introduction to Fallacies

  1. Tutorial F01University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Fallacies and Biases: · read · 30 min

Naming Fallacies

  1. Logical Fallacies HandlistCarson-Newman College · Dr. L. Kip Wheeler · read · 1 h · archived copy
  2. Tutorial F06University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Fallacies and Biases: · read · 2 h · archived copy

A Basic Typology of Fallacies

  1. Tutorials F02–F05University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Fallacies and Biases · read · 1 h · archived copy

Straw Man Fallacy

  1. Critical Thinking Part 3: The Man Who Was Made of StrawYouTube · TechNyou · watch · 15 min

Gambler’s Fallacy

  1. Critical Thinking Part 5: The Gambler’s FallacyYouTube · TechNyou · watch · 15 min

Begging the Question

  1. Begging the QuestionAlternapedia · read · 30 min · no longer online

Red Herring

  1. Red HerringAlternapedia · read · 30 min · no longer online

Ad Hominem (Against the Person)

  1. Ad HominemAlternapedia · * · read · 30 min · no longer online

Ad Ignorantium (Appeal to Ignorance)

  1. Argument from IgnoranceAlternapedia · read · 30 min · no longer online

Ad Populum (Appeal to People)

  1. Argumentum ad PopulumAlternapedia · * · read · 30 min · archived copy

Complex Question (Double-Barreled Question)

  1. Double-Barreled QuestionAlternapedia · read · 30 min · no longer online

Loaded Question

  1. Loaded QuestionAlternapedia · read · 30 min · no longer online

Non Sequitur (It Does Not Follow)

  1. Non SequiturAlternapedia · * · read · 30 min · no longer online

Review of Fallacies in Detail

  1. PHIL102 Discussion ForumThe Saylor Foundation · do · 30 min · archived copy

Cognitive Biases

  1. Tutorial F08University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Fallacies and Biases: · read · 30 min
  2. Lecture 3: Cognitive Biases 1, Lecture 4: Cognitive Biases 2, and Lecture 5: Cognitive Biases 3YouTube · UC Berkeley · Robb Willer’s Sociology 150A · Social Psychology · Self and Society: · read · 4 h

Chapter IV

Basic Sentential Logic

This unit introduces a topic that many students find intimidating: formal logic. Although it sounds difficult and complicated, formal or “symbolic logic” is actually a fairly straightforward way of revealing the structure of reasoning. By translating arguments into symbols, we can more readily see what is right and what is wrong with them, and we can learn how to formulate better arguments.

Tractatus title page 1922 Harcourt
Tractatus title page 1922 Harcourt, Title etc. uncopyrightable; layout by Harcourt Brace, 1922. Public domain

What Logic Is (And What It Is Not)

  1. Tutorial L01University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Basic Logic: · read · 30 min

Logical Statements, Connectives, and Relations

  1. Tutorial L02: Statements and Tutorial L03: Basic ConceptsUniversity of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Professor Joe Lau’s and Professor Jonathan Chan · read · 1.5 h

Logic is Fun!

  1. Tutorial L05 and Tutorial L06University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Professors Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Basic Logic: · read · 1 h

Review of Logics Basics

  1. Logical EquivalenceUniversity of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Critical Thinking Exercises: · write · 30 min

About Formal Logic Systems and How to Write Sentences in SL

  1. Tutorial SL01 and Tutorial SL02University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Sentential Logic: · read · 1 h

Connectives and Truth Tables

  1. Tutorial SL03University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Sentential Logic: · read · 2 h

How to Draw Truth-Tables for More Complicated Statements

  1. Tutorial SL04University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Sentential Logic: · read · 1 h

Properties of Individual Well-Formed Formulas and Relations between Them

  1. Tutorial SL05University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Sentential Logic: · read · 1 h

Understanding Truth-Tables

  1. Chapter 3, Section 2: Truth TablesButte College · Wu Wei-Ming’s iLogic: · read · 2 h · archived copy

How to Translate Ordinary Statements into Symbolic Formulae

  1. Tutorial SL06University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Sentential Logic: · read · 1 h

Formalization Practice

  1. Chapter 3: Introduction and Chapter 3, Section 1: SymbolizationButte College · Wu Wei-Ming’s iLogic: · read · 3 h · archived copy

Two Methods for Determining the Validity of an Argument

  1. Tutorial SL07 and Tutorial SL08University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Sentential Logic: · read · 2 h

Why Sentential Logic Is Not Enough

  1. Tutorial SL10University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Sentential Logic: · read · 30 min

Review of Formal Logic

  1. Review of Formal LogicPurdue University · Charles A. Bouman · read · no longer online

Chapter V

Venn Diagrams

In addition to using predicate logic, the limitations of sentential logic can also be overcome by using Venn diagrams to illustrate statements and arguments. Statements that include general words like “some,” or “few,” as well as absolute words like “every,” “all,” and so on, lend themselves to being represented on paper as circles that may or may not overlap. Venn diagrams are especially helpful when dealing with the logical arguments called syllogisms. Syllogisms are a special type of three-step argument with two premises and a conclusion, which involve “quantifying” terms. In this unit we will learn the basic principles of Venn diagrams, how to use them to represent statements, and how to use them to evaluate arguments.

John Venn 2
John Venn 2, Unknown (Maull & Fox. studio), 1870s. Public domain

Venn Diagrams as Illustrations of Sets or Classes

  1. Introduction and Tutorial V01University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Venn Diagrams: · read · 1 h

More Complicated Venn Diagrams

  1. Tutorial V03University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Venn Diagrams: · read · 30 min

Illustrating Existence with Venn Diagrams

  1. Tutorial V04University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Venn Diagrams: · read · 1 h · archived copy

Review of Introduction to Venn Diagrams

  1. Exercises V01.6University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Venn Diagrams: · write · 30 min · no longer online

Using Venn Diagrams to Evaluate Syllogisms

  1. Tutorial V06University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Venn Diagrams: · read · 30 min

Understanding the Logic of Venn Diagrams

  1. Chapter 2, Section 5: Venn DiagramsButte College · Wu Wei-Ming’s iLogic: · read · 1 h · archived copy

The Limitations of Venn Diagrams

  1. Tutorial V08University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Venn Diagrams: · read · 30 min

Review of Venn Diagrams and Arguments

  1. Tutorial V07University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Venn Diagrams: · write · 30 min
  2. PHIL102 Discussion ForumThe Saylor Foundation · do · 30 min · archived copy

Chapter VI

Scientific Reasoning

Unlike the syllogistic arguments we discussed in the last unit, which are a form of deductive argument, scientific reasoning is empirical. This means that it depends on observation and evidence, not logical principles. Although some principles of deductive reasoning do apply in science, such as the principle of contradiction, scientific arguments are almost always inductive. Instead of truth and falsity, science deals in confirmation and disconfirmation. Nonetheless, there are very specific rules about what constitutes good scientific reasoning, and scientists are trained to be critical of their own inferences as well as those of others in the scientific community. In this unit, we will investigate the standard method of scientific reasoning, the characteristics of good and bad scientific explanations, the principles of confirmation and disconfirmation, and the challenges of reasoning about one of the most important scientific concepts, namely causality.

Portrait of Isaac Newton (1642-1727)label QS:Lde,"Porträt des Isaac Newton (1642-1727)"label QS:Len,"Portrait of Isaac Newton (1642-1727)"label QS:Lfr,"Portrait de Isaac Newton (1642-1727)"label QS:Lhe,"דיוקן אייזק ניוטון"label QS:Les,"Retrato de Isaac Newton (1689)"
Portrait of Isaac Newton (1642-1727), Godfrey Kneller, 1689. Public domain

The Method of Scientific Reasoning

  1. Tutorial S01 and Tutorial S02University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Scientific Methodology: · read · 30 min · no longer online

The Scientific Method, Explained by a Scientist

  1. Episode 8, Part 1 – The Scientific Method and Episode 8, Part 2 – The Scientific MethodYouTube · Ask a Physicist · watch · 30 min

What Makes One Scientific Theory Better than Another

  1. Tutorial S03University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Scientific Methodology: · read · 15 min · archived copy

Review of Basic Principles of Scientific Reasoning

  1. PHIL102 Discussion ForumThe Saylor Foundation · read · 30 min · archived copy

Causality Basics

  1. Tutorial S04University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Scientific Methodology: · read · 30 min

Five Ways to Identify a Cause

  1. Tutorial S05University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Scientific Methodology: · read · 1 h

Causality is More Than Just Cause and Effect

  1. Tutorial S06University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Scientific Methodology: · read · 30 min · no longer online

The Difference between Causation and Correlation

  1. Correlation and CausationCarson-Newman College · Dr. L. Kip Wheeler · read · 30 min · archived copy

Ways of Representing Cause and Effect

  1. Tutorial S07University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Scientific Methodology: · read · 30 min

Fallacies about Causation

  1. Tutorial S08University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Scientific Methodology: · read · 30 min · archived copy

Review of Causation

  1. PHIL102 Discussion ForumThe Saylor Foundation · do · 30 min · archived copy

Chapter VII

Strategic Reasoning and Creativity

While the majority of this course has focused on the types of reasoning that are necessary to critique and evaluate existing knowledge, or to extend our knowledge in accordance with correct procedures and rules, there remains an enormous branch of our reasoning practice that runs “in the opposite direction,” as it were. Strategic reasoning, problem solving, and creative thinking all rely on an ineffable component of novelty supplied by the thinker. Despite the seemingly mystical nature of such activity, however, problem solving and creative thinking are best approached by following a set of tried and tested procedures, which prompt our cognitive faculties to produce new ideas and solutions by extending our existing knowledge. In this unit, we will investigate techniques for problem solving, representing complex problems visually, making decisions in risky and uncertain scenarios, and creative thinking in general.

Problem Solving Begins with Understanding the Problem

  1. Tutorial G01University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Strategic Thinking: · read · 30 min

A Technique for Problem Solving

  1. Tutorial G02University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Strategic Thinking: · read · 15 min

Working with Complex Problems

  1. Tutorial G03University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Strategic Thinking: · read · 15 min

Visual Tools for Strategic Reasoning

  1. Tutorial G04University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Strategic Thinking: · read · 30 min
  2. Decision Tree: Part 1 and Decision Tree: Part 2YouTube · Dr. Farrokh Alemi · watch

Basic Decision Theory

  1. Tutorial G05University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Strategic Thinking: · read · 30 min · archived copy
  2. Decision Theory TutorialRichland Community College · Professor James Jones’ · read · archived copy

Three Principles of Creative Thinking

  1. Tutorial R01University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Creativity: · read · 30 min · archived copy

A Four Step Cycle for Creative Thinking

  1. Tutorial R02University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Creativity: · read · 15 min · archived copy

Heuristics for Creative Thinking and Some Quotations

  1. Tutorial R03 and Tutorial R04University of Hong Kong’s Critical Thinking Web · Joe Lau and Jonathan Chan’s Creativity: · read · 30 min · archived copy

Review of Creative Thinking

  1. PHIL102 Discussion ForumThe Saylor Foundation · do · 30 min · archived copy

About this course

This course is Saylor Academy's PHIL102, Logic and Critical Thinking, one of the complete university courses the Saylor Foundation made free from 2008 and retired in 2015. Saylor licensed its course text under CC BY 3.0; the original is on GitHub. Here it is laid out as chapters, links that have died go to an archived copy from the Internet Archive where one exists, assessments that needed a Saylor login are left out, and people and works are linked to Kulturbase. The readings and lectures belong to their publishers and are linked, not copied. Pictures: Wikimedia Commons, credited under each picture.

All Saylor courses · Free culture courses · The Chautauqua Reading Course